Yellow Pages: How to Increase Leads 1000%

Telmetrics released very interesting results of a *tracking URL* study they conducted from November 2008 to April 2009 with 1200 print Yellow Pages ads. Telmetrics is a long time vendor in the call measurement space. Though several entrants crowded the call tracking market a few years ago - namely VoiceStar, eStara, Ingenio, CallSource, StandardCall and others – Telmetrics has remained independent and reemerged as the leader in the space. I commend the innovation in offering Yellow Page publishers another tool to prove ROI to their local advertisers.

The Telmetrics press release states "Tracking unique URL activity and call measurement reflects a 78 percent increase in leads driven by print Yellow Pages."

I asked Bill Dinan, the new CEO, if leads delivered to the advertiser increased 78% or just the total tracked leads vs tracked calls alone. I assume the leads were previously delivered, just not tracked with a unique URL. The difference is semantic, however. A lead not tracked is basically a lead not delivered in the eyes of the advertiser.

It’s interesting to think about lead quality in this scenario. Is a phone lead 10 or 15 seconds? What constitutes a web lead in a URL tracking study? Do the analytics eliminate referral (search) traffic and only report leads resulting from the print ads? Is a unique web user a lead (impressions)? Or is a web result a lead (email, call, printed coupon)? Without these definitions its hard to make a "call vs web lead" analysis apples to apples.

The Yellow Pages industry needs to fix their leaking bucket, but I am not sure URL tracking is scalable. It’s an interesting offer for a few existing advertisers, and can be used to extrapolate estimates of online leads referred by the print ads. Offering existing call tracking advertisers URL tracking provides deeper reporting to a smaller group of advertisers. Alternatively, and far more effective in my opinion, Yellow Pages publishers, such as AT&T, RHD and Idearc could provide lead reporting to far more advertisers.

If and when the Yellow Pages industry gets serious about saving itself, they will need to prove ROI to many more advertisers. Call tracking usage will have to increase at a multiple of 10X (at a minimum) and either the vendors (such as Telmetrics) or the publishers themselves will need to innovate to insure that quality leads are delivered to merchants and that consumer benefit increases.

Call tracking and voice applications can improve the consumer experience and better match the consumer demand with merchant supply. Publishers will need to embrace voice applications to realize the many benefits of integrating this technology into mobile local search.

If a publisher were increase call tracking usage 10X, they could report that lead delivery increased nearly 1000%.

That’s a headline.